What should you look for when choosing an apron?


In general, there are two different systems available:
Tip: When closing the belt of the coat, lift your shoulders up slightly. Thus, the weight of the coat will partially rest on the hips and will not be completely borne by the shoulders.

Skirt with stretch insert and Coat with stretch belt. Also when wearing front protective aprons the shoulders can be relieved from the total weight burden. Clever inclusions of stretch inserts redistribute the weight and support the back. In order to avoid placing any additional load on the shoulders, radiation protective aprons should always be fitted with soft shoulder pads.
I. Both front panels of the protective apron have the specified lead equivalent value
The only advantage of this option is that the user is always protected with at least the specified lead equivalent value after closing the apron. Disadvantage: Due to the design, there is always an area of overlap, which has twice the lead equivalent value. Consequently, you have to carry more weight than necessary.
II. Both front panels have roughly half the lead equivalent value – overlapping ensures the specified lead equivalent value
In terms of weight, option II is better than option I. However, you need to be aware that the desired lead equivalent value is only achieved in the overlapping area. You should specifically check with the apron manufacturer whether the shoulder parts, where the front panels a lot of times do not overlap, have the full lead equivalent value. In addition, it may happen that the apron is not closed correctly, e.g. due to carelessness. As a result, there may be areas with only half of the specified lead equivalent value.

MAVIG has solved these problems with their patented «Safety Zones». The areas on the sides and on the shoulders separated by seams in the outer material already have the full lead equivalent value. Thus, the shoulder parts are optimally protected and the safety zone on the side makes it easy to correctly adjust the front panels.In order to visually differentiate the safety zones, they are always manufactured in the colour «Titan», regardless of the colour of the apron.
TIP: The safety zones are also an ideal help to check if the correct apron size is chosen. If the front panel ends in the safety zone, the size is right for you.

Does Lead-Free really mean lighter?
When it comes to radiation protection, you can decide between three different types of protective materials: leaded, lead-reduced and lead-free. Unfortunately, many users still think that “lead-free” translates into a lighter protective material and thus, a particularly light protective apron. However, research proves that wrong. The following brief overview of the different protective materials explains the relationship between material and weight:
The standard protective material for shielding against X-rays is lead. Lead is a high-Z-material, meaning an element with a high atomic number, i.e. a high number of protons. A high-Z-material such as lead is very effective at shielding the user from X-rays in the clinically relevant range of 50 – 150 kV almost irrespective of the X-ray tube voltage. So, protective materials with lead have a stable lead equivalent value from 50 – 150 kV. On the downside, a high atomic number means that the protective material has a higher weight.
The standard protective material for shielding against X-rays is lead. Lead is a high-Z-material, meaning an element with a high atomic number, i.e. a high number of protons. A high-Z-material such as lead is very effective at shielding the user from X-rays in the clinically relevant range of 50 – 150 kV almost irrespective of the X-ray tube voltage. So, protective materials with lead have a stable lead equivalent value from 50 – 150 kV. On the downside, a high atomic number means that the protective material has a higher weight.
In lead-free protective materials, lead is completely replaced by another material, which usually has a lower atomic number. Depending on the material, it may be the case that the protective material is considerably lighter for the same surface area. But, as mentioned above, low-Z-materials provide lower protection against certain X-Ray tube voltages than pure lead materials. As lead is completely replaced in lead-free materials, this can cause significant changes in the lead equivalent value, depending on the X-Ray tube voltage. In this case, many times the specified lead equivalent of the protective material is only met at certain x-ray tube voltages. If a different voltage is used, the user’s protection may be significantly lower than expected. But that doesn’t mean that lead-free radiation protective aprons cannot guarantee adequate protection. For example, if you completely replace lead with bismuth, you will be just as protected. On the other hand, as bismuth is directly next to lead in the periodic table, the radiation protective apron would not be lighter.
It is particularly important to ensure that the material does not emit any fluorescent radiation. This is prevented by the two-layer structure of the MAVIG Leadfree Material.
Generally speaking, any material can provide sufficient protection if it is configured correctly. Currently, this is only ensured through the norms IEC 61331:2014 / DIN EN 61331:2016. In order to be adequately protected over the entire X-Ray tube voltage range, it is important that the radiation protective apron maintains a certain weight. This picture shows the lead equivalent values of different serial materials from various manufacturers, determined from 50 kV – 150 kV according to IEC 61331-1:2014. From the determined lead equivalent values, the lowest value was plotted over the surface area weight of the respective material. It is clear that a lower surface area weight goes hand in hand with a lower lead equivalent value and therefore a lower level of protection. The same applies vice versa. A higher lead equivalent value with a correspondingly higher level of protection usually has a higher surface area weight.
Today, it is still possible that some aprons are significantly lighter than others. This is due to the fact that not all manufacturers have changed their production to the latest technology (IEC 61331-1:2014 / DIN EN 61331-1:2016). Radiation protective clothing, which was approved before the introduction of the new standards, retains its CE certification for the time being, which is why it is particularly important to pay attention to the year of the norms/standards.
Why does the lead equivalent value fluctuate with a partial or complete replacement of lead? And why can some radiation protective aprons receive a CE certification despite having a suspiciously light weight?
To clarify these questions, we must take a closer look at the measurement methods used in the past and today to determine the lead equivalent value.
In these standards, the lead equivalent value of a protective material is determined in the narrow beam condition. However, going into the technical details of the determination of the lead equivalent value would go outside the boundaries of this leaflet. What is important to know: When taking the measurement, the measuring chamber is not placed directly behind the sample (the protective material).
Certain «non-lead materials» emit a secondary radiation, so-called fluorescence radiation, when subject to typical medical X-ray tube voltages (80 kV – 100 kV). This fluorescence radiation is low-energy and only has a very small range in the air. Therefore, fluorescence radiation can only be measured directly behind the radiation protection material. If, like with category I, the measuring chamber and the sample are far apart, the fluorescence radiation will not be detected, and therefore the lead equivalent value will be incorrectly measured as higher than its actual value. Consequently, a correct lead equivalent value for all materials can only be determined by using the category II measurement method (or the withdrawn DIN 6857-1:2009).
Moreover, the fluorescence radiation has a greater effect from a biological point of view than the higher-energy scattered radiation that the apron blocks.
In addition, the Category I standards required the determination of the lead equivalent at only one single X-ray tube voltage. As previously shown, the lead equivalent for lead-free or lead-reduced protective materials is highest around an X-ray tube voltage of about 90 kV. Therefore, if one selects this voltage for the determination of the lead equivalent according to the outdated measuring methodology I, the standard would be officially fulfilled, but the wearer would unknowingly be protected far less than assumed when working with other X-ray tube voltages.
You need to load content from reCAPTCHA to submit the form. Please note that doing so will share data with third-party providers.
More InformationYou are currently viewing a placeholder content from Turnstile. To access the actual content, click the button below. Please note that doing so will share data with third-party providers.
More Information